Health Policy

Doctors debate physician-assisted suicide in context of Jewish Holocaust history

Is a patient's right to die more valuable than their life?


By Britni R. McAshan | January 25, 2019

The Center for Medicine after the Holocaust assembled thought leaders from around the world this month to discuss today’s use of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide.

The discussion at the Houston Methodist Research Institute featured Timothy E. Quill, M.D., the Georgia and Thomas Gosnell Distinguished Professor of Palliative Care and Professor of Medicine, Psychiatry, Medical Humanities and Nursing at the University of Rochester School of Medicine in New York, and Avraham Steinberg, M.D., a rabbi who is Director of the Medical Ethics Unit at Shaare Zedek Medical Center in Jerusalem.

The conversation, with roots in history, culture and legislation, was informed by experimental medical practices used by Nazi doctors during the Holocaust and World War II.

Medical students of yesteryear often began their educations by taking the Hippocratic Oath, which asks them to abstain from euthanasia. Most recently minted physicians take vows aside from the classical version that focus broadly on attending to the well-being of the souls in their care.

During the Holocaust, Nazi physicians were involved in medical experimentation that targeted Jews and other captives in concentration camps that caused harm and were conducted without consent.

In the United States today, assisted suicide—the voluntary termination of one’s own life by administration of a lethal substance with the direct or indirect assistance of a physician—is legal in California, Colorado, Hawaii, Oregon, Vermont, Washington and the District of Columbia. (Montana law does not prohibit a physician from honoring a patient’s request to hasten death.)

According to the state’s Advance Directives Act, “mercy killing” is not condoned in Texas. Under state law, physician-assisted suicide or using medical intervention to bring death sooner than its natural occurrence is also unlawful. Texas allows passive withdrawal of life support, but does not allow medical intervention to hasten death.

More than a decade ago, the Texas Medical Association convened a task force to study physician-assisted suicide. The TMA then and now continues to support the American Medical Association’s position that physician-assisted suicide “is fundamentally incompatible with the physician’s role as healer.”

“We as physicians don’t have the right solution for what is the best way to die or even to treat a dying patient because it is primarily a social question. It has ethical, legal, religious, cultural and other aspects, far beyond medicine,” Steinberg said. “I think physician assisted suicide and euthanasia interferes with the physician’s role and ethos. A physician is not an executioner of society. His role is not to kill people—it is to care for people.”

In 1996, before physician-assisted suicide became a top-of-mind topic, Quill testified before a U.S. House subcommittee to argue his position on its merits. In Houston, he explained that physician-assisted suicide was legalized in Canada in 2016 because legislators determined that the choice was a fundamental right because people are living much longer.

“The hope was that people would live healthy for quite a bit longer, that they would live sick perhaps for a shorter time and that they would die peacefully. That is unfortunately, not the way this has transpired,” Quill said. “They are living sick a lot longer and at the end of sick, we are often faced with very difficult decisions about whether to keep going or whether to stop. How much is too much? And, about half the time, those people are no longer able to participate personally in that decision.”

There is also the role of relieving suffering—part of palliative care—that explains why a physician would participate in hastening the end of life, he added.

“Physician-assisted dying should have safeguards to protect the vulnerable from error, abuse, coercion—to make sure that people have access to adequate palliative care—and that the reasons for physician-assisted suicide are present for last resort options,” Quill said. “Whether we choose to allow physician-assisted suicide or not, we still have to consider severe suffering prior to death as a medical emergency, so saying no to these practices does not solve the problem.”

Steinberg noted reasons why physicians should not end lives.

“The fact is that people are suffering and we have to find solutions. I think if we go back to the two major principles—the value of life and the principle of autonomy—we ought to find a balancing road. But, if we accept the principle that life has an inherent value and should never be breached, that is the limiting factor on what we can do for patients,” he said. “Once the taboo of taking someone’s life is breached, it is very hard to control. … Inherently, unrelated to the consequences, there is never an ethical justification to take another person’s life—actively, deliberately—it doesn’t matter what the reason is for doing it.”

Steinberg is a medical ethicist who has authored several volumes of the “Encyclopedia of Jewish Medical Ethics” and is the former chair of Israel’s National Advisory Committee to the Minister of Health for Enacting a Law Concerning the Terminally Ill.

In Houston, he argued that adequate palliative care was essential for patients and their families at the end of life, but he doesn’t believe that all requests from patients are motivated by pain.

“In many cases, it is not a fully competent and autonomous decision. This is a decision that a person chooses because they do not want to be a burden upon others or because of economical situations,” he added. “This may turn from a right to die into a duty to die.”

The Center for Medicine after the Holocaust, a Houston-based organization founded in 2010, aims to bring Holocaust education to the medical community as well as to challenge physicians, nurses and bioscientists to “personally confront the medical ethics of the Holocaust and apply that knowledge to contemporary practice and research,” according to its mission statement.




Social Posts

profile_image

MD Anderson Cancer Center

@MDAndersonNews

How our Moon Shots Program is changing the way we detect and treat #cancer: https://t.co/10KSeMrBlf #CancerMoonshot #endcancer

38 mins ago
profile_image

Rice University

@RiceUniversity

RT @RiceBaseball: A series win looks even better through the 📸 #GoOwls👐 x #NewEraSameStandard https://t.co/dPDNQvPxf3

1 hour ago
profile_image

Veterans Affairs

@DeptVetAffairs

GONZALEZ, Texas: Important Veterans fair scheduled for March 16 https://t.co/dQk55UwBF3 via @GonzInquirer

2 hours ago
profile_image

Veterans Affairs

@DeptVetAffairs

Las Cruces Veteran building race cart to raise awareness about Veterans' issues https://t.co/jAQXxf0rKv via @CrucesSunNews

3 hours ago
profile_image

MD Anderson Cancer Center

@MDAndersonNews

@CourtWilkinson6 @ABREG_1 Let us know if you need anything while you’re here, Courtney. We’re sending good vibes your way.

4 hours ago
profile_image

Veterans Affairs

@DeptVetAffairs

Today’s #VeteranOfTheDay is Women’s Army Corps Veteran Martha Settle Putney. Martha served during World War II. https://t.co/9RaNBEC8Ef

4 hours ago
profile_image

MD Anderson Cancer Center

@MDAndersonNews

Dr. Greg Lizee on novel treatment vaccine: “We’re pioneering the #colorectalcancer field, but this therapy could potentially be used to treat any type of cancer.” #endcancer https://t.co/dV67DvDBG5

5 hours ago
profile_image

University of Houston

@UHouston

RT @UHCougarMBK: No 9/9 COOGS WIN!!! Final score presented by @thejointchiro UH moves to 2️⃣5️⃣-1️⃣ overall 1️⃣2️⃣-1️⃣ in #AmericanHoops…

5 hours ago
profile_image

BCMHouston

@bcmhouston

Can't fall asleep? Can't stop hitting the snooze on your alarm in the morning? Light may be to blame. https://t.co/KITEIEWypI #sleep #sleepmedicine

6 hours ago
profile_image

Rice University

@RiceUniversity

RT @RiceBaseball: Rice Wins! Rice Wins! 🦉👐 https://t.co/SdprR4IGG8

7 hours ago
profile_image

BCMHouston

@bcmhouston

RT @ashleyhmullen: Our OP students did a wonderful job teaching girls about a career in orthotics and prosthetics at the @hmns GEMS event!…

8 hours ago
profile_image

BCMHouston

@bcmhouston

RT @HOUmanitarian: Million Dollar Baby: An upcoming conversation hosted by @bcmhouston examines how IVF and other reproductive technologies…

8 hours ago
profile_image

University of Houston

@UHouston

Big issues. Bold ideas. UH-mazing support. https://t.co/Bmcxjtzpiq

10 hours ago
profile_image

University of Houston

@UHouston

RT @UHCougarMBK: IT'S 🏀 GAME DAY in NEW ORLEANS! 🐾 🏀 at Tulane 🕗 1 pm 📍 Fogelman Arena in Devlin Fieldhouse 💻 @CBSSportsNet | https://t.…

11 hours ago
profile_image

Houston Methodist

@MethodistHosp

@SamRRazaMD @DrMarthaGulati @NadeenFaza @WilliamZoghbi @rooshaparikh @AChoiHeart @HeartOTXHeartMD @purviparwani @ErinMichos @mmamas1973 @iamritu @VietHeartPA @ash71us @mswami001 @onco_cardiology @majazayeri Glad you liked it. Thanks for the shout-out

12 hours ago