Clinical

What Frankenstein Can Teach Clinicians About Patient Care

Like Frankenstein, clinicians’ desire to overcome death can overwhelm their sensitivity to the suffering of patients.


franky Source: Wikimedia Commons
By Andrew Childress, Ph.D. | October 30, 2018

Andrew Childress, Ph.D., is an assistant professor at Baylor College of Medicine’s Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy.

Streets will soon fill with children walking door-to-door in costumes. One of the most “classic” costumes comes from a 200-year old book by Mary Shelley — Frankenstein. For decades kids have sported the green face paint, a flattop and neck bolts. But they’ve got it all wrong. Frankenstein is the surname of the scientist who created the monster (aka, the Creature) out of discarded corpses and, most likely, a healthy dose of electricity.

In Shelley’s book, the Creature himself was never given a name and bears no resemblance to the grunting green monster seen in movies, television and elsewhere. Instead, he’s an intelligent, articulate, sensitive being who quotes poets like John Milton and implores Frankenstein to regard him as an equal and treat him with compassion.

Frankenstein is often cited as a cautionary tale, one that forecasts the dire consequences of allowing scientific and technological innovation to run amok. While this is a useful reading of the novel, there are other valuable lessons to be learned from the conflict between Frankenstein and his creation that can be applied to the world of modern medicine.

Innovations in critical care, thoracic surgery and transplant medicine have enabled health care providers to prolong life, despite failure of vital organs and organ systems. However, these technical successes (and failures) have consequences for the patients whose lives are saved. Although their lives may be prolonged by these technologies, patients may feel that the tradeoffs in terms of dramatic changes in their body image, their struggles to reintegrate into society and the burdens placed on their family members may not be worth a few extra months or even years of life. For example, patients with severe heart failure who receive implantable ventricular assist devices may be able to leave the hospital and resume some of their usual activities, but they will have to take care of a complex mechanical device that may limit their independence and mobility.

And when these life-sustaining or prolonging treatments fail, it is often difficult for clinicians to openly acknowledge this fact, let alone the suffering that these treatments can produce. Like Frankenstein, clinicians’ desire to overcome death can overwhelm their sensitivity to the suffering of patients and their families. The patient’s body then becomes a battlefield for the eternal struggle to stave off death and avoid feelings of grief and loss. In other words, the patients’ desires for compassion and palliation may become secondary to clinicians’ desires to “beat” death. When this happens, patients often feel rejected or abandoned by the clinical care team—just as the Creature felt abandoned by Frankenstein. What they need then is someone to help rebuild their sense of self and return them to an environment of caring and compassion.

Like many patients who suffer from acute, chronic or catastrophic illnesses, Frankenstein’s Creature felt alone, disoriented, and rejected by his Creator and by society at large. He had deep spiritual and existential needs that Frankenstein either ignored or refused to address. These needs included the need to be known, to be listened to, and to feel cared for by those around him. Clinicians have a unique opportunity every day to identify and address these needs as part of the pathway to healing. They can start by listening to the patient’s story of illness and imagining themselves as characters in that story. They can ask themselves what story the patient might tell of their clinic visit or their hospitalization and how they might describe the care they received to others. They can also ask the patient what role medicine can play in helping them write the next chapter of their lives, one that avoids Frankenstein’s mistakes and leads down the path to healing instead of alienation, despair and suffering.

Want to learn more about what Frankenstein can teach health care providers? Register here for the Baylor College of Medicine Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy’s Conversation Speaker Series event on  Dec. 13.  Assistant Professor Andrew Childress will discuss issues related to trust in medicine, the acknowledgment of suffering, and the unintended consequences of using advanced life-sustaining technologies, drawing on insights from the interaction between Frankenstein and the Creature to help illuminate the experiences of patients who have felt abandoned or have lost trust in medicine.




Social Posts

profile_image

Veterans Affairs

@DeptVetAffairs

104-year-old Veteran asks for Valentine's cards https://t.co/hM0xtGicki via @KOLO8

8 hours ago
profile_image

Veterans Affairs

@DeptVetAffairs

New tool at Asheville VA helps Veterans connect with their doctors from home https://t.co/AVOKMPHFRB via @WLOS_13

10 hours ago
profile_image

MD Anderson Cancer Center

@MDAndersonNews

“Art is an empowering and effective means of expression,” says our Kasey Marsh.Read how @childrensart is helping @KidsandCancer patients like Lara Amer cope with cancer: https://t.co/uPTzLFeUZT #endcancer

10 hours ago
profile_image

Veterans Affairs

@DeptVetAffairs

New assisted living facility at Colmery O’Neil VA Medical Center ‘feels like home’ for Veteran https://t.co/1QTYDsHBp9 via @KSNTNews

12 hours ago
profile_image

MD Anderson Cancer Center

@MDAndersonNews

“My advice is do exactly what they say,” says singer James McManus, who regained his voice by following our Dr. Stephen Lai’s recommendations after #throatcancer surgery. #endcancer https://t.co/Phq1o5Ynic

12 hours ago
profile_image

BCMHouston

@bcmhouston

We will be closed tomorrow Monday, Jan. 20 in observance of Martin Luther King, Jr. Day. We will reopen Tuesday, Jan. 21. https://t.co/UtHKw8Ov6H

13 hours ago
profile_image

Houston Methodist

@MethodistHosp

Are Juice Cleanses Actually Good for You? 🍎🍌🥑🥒🍋How fruits and veggies can be too much of a good thing.https://t.co/M05fuPhpcf https://t.co/lcKuO6eOJu

14 hours ago
profile_image

MD Anderson Cancer Center

@MDAndersonNews

When Tralisa Woods was first diagnosed with #uterinecancer, she didn’t want to travel from her home in Dallas for treatment. But, after her first trip to MD Anderson, she knew she was in the right place: https://t.co/iCEfVL0tGj @MAOnstad #gyncsm #endcancer

14 hours ago
profile_image

BCMHouston

@bcmhouston

The flu season is only just ramping up. Here is what you need to know about this year's season. https://t.co/Yibv9afdxo #flu #fluseason

17 hours ago
profile_image

BCMHouston

@bcmhouston

What is the low-FODMAP diet? Ann McMeans, senior registered dietitian, breaks it all down. https://t.co/EltAwzjbJ4 #diets #lowFODMAPdiet

19 hours ago
profile_image

Rice University

@RiceUniversity

RT @RiceUNews: TODAY: In celebration of the life of Martin Luther King Jr., @RiceUniversity’s Black Male Leadership Initiative will host a…

20 hours ago
profile_image

Houston Methodist

@MethodistHosp

The @HoustonMarathon forecast looks perfect... but don't forget these 2️⃣things.🏃‍♂️ 🏃‍♀️ https://t.co/oXDfdkZklk https://t.co/M6rCAFrj2z

1 day ago
profile_image

University of Houston

@UHouston

RT @UHCougarMBK: COOGS WIN!... Final score presented by @thejointchiro@LaDeeky | 12 pts | 9 rebs | 6 asts @3five_ | 14 pts | 5 rebs @msa…

1 day ago
profile_image

University of Houston

@UHouston

@MsLoyeEngIV Nice work, Douglas! #GoCoogs

1 day ago
profile_image

TexasHeartInstitute

@Texas_Heart

Today at THI, Harvard Professor, Christine Edry Seidman, MD, was honored with the 40th Ray C Fish Award for Scientific Achievement, @Texas_Heart Institute’s highest honor. https://t.co/i9X5qYwNwz

2 days ago