New anti-smoking advertisements look like nothing consumers have seen before.
The ads display plain black text on a plain white background. There are no images of any kind. A monotone, seemingly robotic voice reads the text, with no vocal inflection and no music in the background.
If it seems like the advertisements violate every rule of Advertising 101, that’s intentional.
“They don’t want these things to be attention-grabbing,” said Lorraine Reitzel, Ph.D., chair of the Department of Psychological, Health and Learning Sciences at the University of Houston College of Education.
The ads are the result of legal negotiations that date back to court rulings from 2006 that have finally been resolved. Experts say every aspect of these ads—from content to font sizes—was litigated. The result: a series of nondescripts advertisements that, in some ways, may stand out because they’re so plain.
In the court-ordered advertisements, which are airing on broadcast television and in print in major newspapers, cigarette-makers offer “corrective statements,” acknowledging that smoking kills, nicotine is addictive, and the cigarette makers designed cigarettes to make them more addictive. They also acknowledge the dangers of secondhand smoke.
The tobacco companies aren’t taking a modern approach to outreach, and experts say that’s also by design. The messages air in prime time slots on broadcast television networks and in print newspapers like the New York Times and Washington Post. Those are not considered optimal ways of targeting young people.
“The ads have no appeal,” said Jennifer Cofer, MPH, director of the EndTobacco Program at The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center. “They’re not going to spark any interest in youth.”
Reitzel pointed to another major shortcoming of the ads: Conspicuously absent from them is any mention of how smokers can find resources to help them quit.
Despite their shortcomings, though, the ads are a “huge public health win,” Cofer said.
“This is what we wanted to see—that they don’t deny their marketing tactics,” Cofer said. “They can no longer misrepresent themselves.”
If the production value of the commercials doesn’t stand out, their plainspoken frankness—of knowingly marketing deadly, addictive products—might.
“These are messages that, thanks to the public health community, have been communicated for a long time,” said Ernest Hawk, M.D., MPH, vice president and division head for cancer prevention and population sciences at The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center. “The new part is who is sending the message. It’s the same message, from a difference source.”
The advertisements come at a convenient time for cigarette-makers, Reitzel said. Smoking rates are declining quickly, so cigarette companies are already designing new ways of delivering tobacco and nicotine to consumers. The companies are admitting to their misdeeds about cigarettes at a time when cigarettes represent a shrinking portion of their portfolio.
Still, it’s significant that tobacco companies can no longer deny the addictive nature of nicotine or the dangers of secondhand smoke, Cofer said. Because the court-ordered advertising is so dry, the public health and advocacy communities will likely use the cigarette makers’ words in their own messaging, she said.
But there’s something to be said for the unusually austere advertisements.
“It may be that they’re so odd—so unlike any other marketing—that perhaps they might get attention,” Hawk said.
RAPID CITY, SD: World War II Veterans from across the Black Hills gather for annual luncheon https://t.co/XsO0DewfB1 via @NewsCenter1
Connecticut: West Haven Memorial Day parade to be led by Vietnam Veteran https://t.co/Fu8JWSJP6l via @nhregister
RT @FOX26Houston: UTHealth preps for approaching hurricane season https://t.co/Pk4HLVM4ny https://t.co/QoNMZxmcID
Today we honor Navy SEAL Veteran Scott Wirtz in remembrance of his service and sacrifice for our country. https://t.co/rkkOXObR3P #VeteranOfTheDay #CarryTheLoad #NoVeteranEverDies
10% of patients are admitted to MD Anderson with #pneumonia. Our @ScottEvansMD is working to protect #cancer patients from this and other lung diseases with a new aerosol treatment: https://t.co/Pbn9mjV7FT @CancerFrontline #endcancer
@obstudiotexas We appreciate your feedback and have shared your concern with the appropriate contact person.
RT @UHpres: After beating Texas A&M, Cougar Softball beats Sam Houston...will play winner of UT/TAMU tomorrow at chance to win out Texas Re…
RT @UHCougarSB: BALL GAMEEEEE!!!!!!!! @presbell17 retires the side in order and completes the shutout victory!!#hoUSton #GoCoogs https://…
RT @NCAAsoftball: The Coogs are heading to the Regional Finals for the first time since 2011! @UHCougarSB blanks Sam Houston State, 5-0, an…
Help give hope to patients against end-stage illnesses by investing in cancer research. Learn how you can help: https://t.co/4T5JCqKmZm #giving https://t.co/vFmZoE73jN
“We’re exploring the tremendous opportunities to understand the immune system and turn it against #prostatecancer tumors,” says our Dr. Filippo Giancotti. #pcsm #CancerMoonshot #endcancer https://t.co/kSvhY7RLR6
Congratulations to this year’s @MDA_UTHGrad graduates! We are proud of all that you’ve accomplished and look forward to seeing all that you do to #endcancer and advance the biomedical sciences in the years ahead. https://t.co/lWYhJk3zLd
CHI St. Luke's Health@CHI_StLukes
Cramps, bloating, mood swings... #PMS can be a pain, so check out some of our favorite tips for easing the discomfort: https://t.co/kRYPi3shyx #NWHW #WomensHealthWeek https://t.co/9FYXvDjXtD
Tiny object, BIG project. How a Rice photographer captured the perfect shot for the cover of @sciencemagazine: https://t.co/lvgpYNfXLm https://t.co/5sPrElM1Lw
Harris Health System@harrishealth
LBJ Hospital celebrated #NationalHospitalWeek with an ice cream sundae bar, popcorn, photo booth day and salsa tasting contest. https://t.co/9slCsNDHM3