Late last year, after decades in Massachusetts, THOMAS MacGILLIVRAY, M.D., traded Boston winters for Houston summers and became Houston Methodist’s chief of cardiac surgery and thoracic transplant. While many heart surgeons work with congenital heart disease in children, MacGillivray is bringing attention to congenital heart disease in adults.
Q | Tell us about your background.
A | I grew up in the Boston area. I had my education and training up in the Boston area. I trained in surgery and cardiac surgery at Massachusetts General Hospital, and I stayed there for almost 19 years after I finished training.
Q | What made you decide to go into cardiac surgery?
A | My dad was a surgeon. My dad had trained in internal medicine, too, first, but decided to be a surgeon. I consciously made a decision to keep an open mind. So I literally went through all of my rotations in the third and fourth year of medical school with that approach.
When I did pediatrics, I approached it with the idea that I want to be a pediatrician. When I did psychiatry, I approached it as, I’m going to do this rotation like I want to be a psychiatrist. I loved every minute of medical school, but I ended where I started. I wanted to be a surgeon.
I don’t know why, but I remember specifically the first day of my internship. They had a little lunch for us. One of the administrators said to me, ‘Well, what kind of surgeon do you want to be? And I said, ‘Well, I don’t really know. I’m really interested in pediatric surgery, maybe trauma, but I want to keep an open mind. But I know for absolute certainty that I don’t want to be a heart surgeon.’
I’d never done a cardiac surgery rotation. Back in those days, cardiac surgery was sort of a juggernaut in medicine, and I had these misconceptions that all it was you did was two or three operations and there wasn’t really any thinking or patient care involved. We spent a lot of time during our residency training on the cardiac surgery service, and I realized it was completely the opposite of what I thought—except for it being technically very demanding, which it continues to be. One of my professors once said, ‘General surgery is like flying a Cessna, but cardiac surgery is like flying an F-14.’ And he’s right.
Q | What did you learn about cardiac surgery during those formative years?
A | You had to be ever-vigilant about what was happening with the patient. Patients could be very, very unstable, very sick. With really precise operations, you’d make people much better—not just keep them from dying, but allow them to have a much-improved quality of life. If you did a very good operation, the patient did well. If you didn’t do a very good operation, you could take somebody who was not that sick and kill them. The management of patients in post-operative care, in the intensive care unit, required really intensive care. You have to be able to identify subtle changes in their course and intervene. I found it exciting, exhilarating really. You could actually see yourself getting better at it the further along you went.
And then, my exposure to congenital heart disease was that, but on steroids. You found these poor babies or poor kids that had these terrible problems, and you could make them better and allow them to go have a normal life. That’s what attracted me to cardiac surgery, and still keeps me excited about cardiac surgery.
Q | On television, cardiac surgeons are typically portrayed as cutthroat and competitive. Do you see that as a truth or a misleading stereotype?
A | I think there is some truth or certainly some basis to the stereotypes in us, and I think that’s becausecertain personality types tend to be attracted to certain kinds of specialties. For some of the reasons I stated, heart disease is a terrible problem in that it requires an intensity, it requires a focus. It mandates that you make decisions quickly. If you’re right, the patient does well, and if you’re wrong, the patient may suffer some consequences. So you have to be pretty sure of yourself.
Q | What led you to Houston?
A | Out of the blue I got a phone call from former TMC President and CEO Bobby Robbins, M.D., who I had known. The heart surgery community around the country is pretty small, so you get to know people, and some people very well. Bobby, a heart surgeon himself, is such a great guy, and it’s extremely easy to like him. He said, ‘They’re looking for a chief of cardiac surgery at Methodist. I think you’d be a good fit for it. Why don’t you come down and visit?’
So, I did. To be honest with you, I didn’t think I was going to come here. I had never been to the Texas Medical Center. I heard about it. It’s a world-famous place. It’s kind of like being a young adult and having never been to Disney World. For no other reason, I thought it’d be great to come down and see first-hand what I’d heard about for my whole medical professional life.
Q | You decided to stay, so, obviously, you liked what you saw.
A | I did. Literally, when I first stepped out of the taxi, I was overwhelmed by just the sheer size of the Texas Medical Center. Surgeons tend to like history, and they certainly like or tend to have hero worship, and there are plenty of surgical heroes that over the years have been here. Between those two things, it was overwhelming.
But what impressed me more than anything were the possibilities for the future. Having spent time talking with Alan Lumsden, M.D., [chief of cardiovascular surgery at Houston Methodist DeBakey Heart & Vascular Center] and Osama Gaber, M.D., [director of the Houston Methodist J.C. Walter Jr. Transplant Center and professor of surgery at Houston Methodist and Weill Cornell Medical College] and a whole list of people, they seemed very intelligent, very accomplished, very excited and had great vision for where they wanted to take Methodist.
Q | How did you first get involved with adult congenital heart disease?
A | One of the cardiologists at Mass General was one of the very first people to take an interest in adult congenital heart disease, and he and I partnered together.
Q | Is there a difference between congenital heart disease in adults and congenital heart disease in children?
A | That’s a really good question. If you ask most people, they would think that congenital heart disease or congenital heart surgery involves kids. For a long time that was true, but the pediatric cardiologists and the pediatric cardiac surgeons over the last 50 years have done such a great job, there are now more adults who have congenital heart disease than children.
Congenital heart disease would be heart defects that you’re born with as opposed to what we refer to as acquired heart disease—things that you develop throughout life due to risk factors or misfortune, like coronary artery disease, aortic valve stenosis, mitral valve prolapse or aortic aneurysms.
We’re learning that things we thought we fixed when patients were children, as it turns out, maybe weren’t fixed forever. Some of the repairs start to develop problems or they develop problems related to their repairs. Physicians solved the problem then, but they created a problem for now.
There are people who have congenital heart disease that was repaired who have now developed acquired heart disease. In order to be able to manage that, you have to have a real understanding of both of those kinds of problems. It’s in that way very much a new frontier.
Q | Since you say adult congenital heart disease is a new frontier, where would you like to see it go?
A | Adult congenital heart disease is a gathering storm, if you will. There are a whole lot of patients who were treated and, at the time, were told that they were cured. They are no longer children, so they don’t see the pediatrician or cardiologist that knew about it, and they don’t necessarily realize that they may have an evolving congenital heart problem.
This is a bit controversial, if you will, but the expertise with congenital heart disease in the past, and, for a large part, in the present, is at pediatric hospitals. This burgeoning field of adult congenital heart disease is an issue with adults in that they now have adult congenital heart disease and they also have other adult problems. Many of us, me included, think that they would be best managed in an adult hospital with people who have an expertise with adult congenital heart disease.
What I would like to see is centers like ours help get the word out to those patients who may or may not know that they need to be evaluated. I would like the resources to be available to those patients—not only at our center, but at other centers. I do think that with the team we have here, we’re uniquely positioned to help lead that way.
Q | I read that you helped a girl from Haiti with her heart disease. Have you had certain opportunities during your career that have made you especially proud?
A | At the risk of sounding like a Boy Scout, I truly consider it a privilege to be able to take care of people. I’m humbled and honored that somebody would come to my office and ask me to take care of them. People trust you. They trust your judgment. They trust your knowledge. They trust your technical abilities. I take that as a true sacred trust, I really do.
When I was training medical students and residents over the years, my No. 1 rule was always be nice to the patient. That’s one of the things my dad taught me. Before I started my residency, he said, ‘Tom, the most important thing about being a doctor isn’t being famous or writing papers or being a professor. The most important thing is taking care of the patient. You can’t always make the right diagnosis. You can’t always cure every disease. But you can always be nice to the patient.’ Oftentimes, that’s the most effective medicine and therapy you can bring to them.
A cardiologist in the greater Boston area when I was up there, went on a mission to Haiti. He had been going back and forth, and he took his son down, who was a high school student, just to give him a transformational experience. The cardiologist was going to donate an EKG machine from his office to this clinic.
While getting it set up, he put it on his son and he saw that his son had an abnormal EKG. So here he is down in Haiti, doesn’t really have access to any advanced evaluation, they’re down there for two weeks, and he saw that his son had a significant cardiac problem. He had a treatable kind of congenital heart disease, so I operated on him and he did very well.
When the cardiologist brought his son in for his post-op evaluation, we were talking and he asked me if I would take care of a girl he met in Haiti who had terrible heart disease, but no one to take care of her. I agreed that if we could figure out a way to get her up here, I’d take care of her. They did, and I did. I’ve been fortunate to be able to help take care of a lot of people over the years.
Thomas MacGillivray, M.D., was interviewed by Pulse reporter Christine Hall. This interview has been edited for clarity and length.
@MasonBiohealth @MTEC_SC Appreciate the shout-out
@MTEC_SC Thanks for the shout-out
@RiceWBB We are so proud of @RiceWBB! You are all amazing and talented athletes. Thank you for representing Rice! 🦉💙👐
@CCISDAthletics Thanks for the shout-out
RT @RiceEngineering: So proud of @RiceWBB and your amazing season! #GoOwls https://t.co/1ULFwIJsJC
Harris Health SystemHarrisHealthSystem
Baylor College of Medicine medical student Larry Vernier talks about the Art and Music in Patient Care Program. Thanks again for serenading our patients!
VA Receives $25 Million Donation to Provide Genetic Testing for Veterans https://t.co/JUKv19jFfX via @Militarydotcom
Harris Health SystemHarrisHealthSystem
Thanks to Baylor College of Medicine students Maria Vigil, Natasha Mehta, Larry Vernier and Geordyn Hoge for serenading Smith Clinic patients this afternoon. The team is part of Baylor’s Art and Music in Patient Care Program.
MD Anderson Cancer Center@MDAndersonNews
“Our goal is to cure the disease, not just treat the symptoms,” says #leukemia expert @WWierda: https://t.co/nOrIIlyRrG #endcancer
Drs. Sophia Fantus and Nicolás Cortés-Pendfield with the @BCMEthics take a look at the new physician guidelines for pre-exposure prophylaxis (PreEP). https://t.co/GVMVsLik2l #ethics #HIV https://t.co/esqNRx5CWB
Baylor College of MedicineBaylorCollegeOfMedicine
We've made it into the Elite 8 in STAT Madness! Help our research on a common antibiotic that has been shown to damage the heart make it into the Final 4 by voting today. #STATMadness
RT @RiceWBB: LOUD NOISES!Ogwumike hits the long J. Rice up 52-43 w/2:40 to go.#GoOwls👐 x #Fight4Greatness
MD Anderson Cancer Center@MDAndersonNews
“If you can prevent your child from having cancer, why wouldn’t you do it?”Watch to hear Scott Courville’s story of overcoming HPV-related #tonsilcancer and why he now advocates for the #HPV vaccine. #hncsm #CancerMoonshot #endcancer https://t.co/Z2E6r82nvb
97-year-old WWII veteran proud to still be working at New Jersey grocery store https://t.co/MSVhqwNSPY via @ABC7NY
TAMU Health Sciences@TAMHSC
The Texas A&M School of Public Health recognized at national meeting for outstanding community service. https://t.co/ah4gglROHN#TAMUHealth https://t.co/ZNpYbxrKk5