Texas lawmakers and Doris Taylor, Ph.D., director of regenerative medicine research at the Texas Heart Institute, gathered at Rice University recently for a panel discussion to discuss the implications of the recently-passed Charlie’s Law.
Named in honor of the late Texas State Rep. Charlie Howard, Charlie’s Law (Texas HB 810) is the brainchild of state Rep. Tan Parker. Charlie’s Law expands the right-to-try laws in Texas, allowing patients with chronic and terminal illnesses access to experimental stem cell interventions in the state. This is the first law of its kind in the country.
“For me, I’ve really come to this from a personal story,” said Parker, a panelist at the Oct. 4 event. “My wife has suffered from chronic illness for many, many years, and through her eyes and her experiences I started learning about adult stem cells. That really opened my eyes to the importance of this for everybody. And for me, it became an issue fundamentally of medical freedom and medical liberty. Why can’t someone who is of age have the ability to sign off with regards to a proper medical release for something that can make such dramatic difference in their lives?”
Charlie’s Law passed unanimously in the 85th Legislature on June 12 and was signed into law by Gov. Greg Abbott. At present, many Texans and other Americans are traveling around the world to receive stem cell therapies that have been unavailable and illegal in the United States. Stem cells are used used in a number of ways to treat cancer, neurological disorders, diabetes, heart disease and much more.
However beneficial stem cells may be for the future of human health, research in stem cells and regenerative medicine has been a source of controversy in the United States for decades. Patients would have to absorb the cost of these therapies, which could be harmful or ineffective.
In his introduction to the panel discussion, James T. Willerson, M.D., president emeritus at the Texas Heart Institute, explained just what stem cells are.
“All of us should recognize that we are products of stem cells,” Willerson said to the audience at the event, which was hosted by the Baker Institute’s Center for Health and Biosciences and the Texas Heart Institute. “So when one says, ‘I really don’t believe in stem cells,’ they really don’t understand. Around the age of 60, our stem cells become dysfunctional. Our maker gave us these stem cells to repair our heart, our spinal cord. And in life, when we often most need them, they don’t work.”
As one of the world’s best-known researchers in the field of regenerative medicine, Taylor said she looks forward to the doors Charlie’s Law will open for researchers and patients.
“One of the benefits of this law is that it is going to give us a lot more data,” said Taylor , who has been researching stem cells and regenerative medicine for more than two decades and is passionate about their ability to heal. But she cautioned her fellow panelists—Tan, state Sen. Paul Bettencourt, state Rep. Garnet Coleman, state Sen. Charles Schwertner and state Rep. John Zerwas—about the need for scrutiny and transparency in the research process.
“I’d like to remind people that regenerative medicine is unlike anything else we’ve ever dealt with in the world of medicine,” Taylor said. “It’s not like a drug you take and six hours later it is gone and you’ve metabolized it. Regenerative therapies stick around. … You can’t take them back. So I think what that means is that the burden of proof is a little bit higher.”
Taylor explained to the audience that a stem cell can do two things: it can make more of itself and it can differentiate into other kinds of cells. She quickly pointed out that a cell that can proliferate and differentiate is also the definition of a tumor cell.
“Personally, I am a cancer survivor,” Taylor said to the crowd. “I understand the need to find new therapies and I strongly believe in novel, innovative approaches, and yet, I want those vetted. When I needed a therapy, I called Dr. Willerson. I can call any doctor in town and find out whether or not it is safe and that is what we need for patients in this field. It’s our job to make sure innovation happens and it can happen safely. It’s incumbent upon us to be transparent. … Let’s publish negative data. You can’t publish a negative study right now—it’s hard to do—so you won’t know if a cell didn’t work, you only know if it worked.”
This spiced beet salad is a sure crowd-pleaser to bring to your #holiday gathering. Get the recipe here: https://t.co/V65Qt0OcnM. #healthyfood https://t.co/VsuU5nrMn0
Even though this lightweight material is full of holes, it's nearly as hard as diamond and stops bullets better than solid materials: https://t.co/N1QBG6C6yz https://t.co/CZTLL3qyDf
Today’s #VeteranOfTheDay is Army Veteran Boris A. Stern, who fought at the Battle of the Bulge and Battle of the Rhineland during World War II: https://t.co/4GVemb8y4p
Dr. Lisa Gaw, pediatrician and director at Texas Children’s Urgent Care Westgate, weighs in via @austin360: https://t.co/krYY7O3tuR
RT @austin360: The holidays are upon us, and so is the increased eating and the risk of choking. Make sure you know what to do ⤵ https://t.…
RT @LinaHidalgoTX: Today I toured the Texas Children’s Hospital @TexasChildrens to learn about the incredible work that they do. The amazin…
How is your social media habits effecting your kids? Dr. Laurel Williams explains. https://t.co/04xUcmpG93 #socialmedia #mentalhealth
RT @ARosen380: True honor and privilege to present today on our work in Colorectal Cancer Outreach and education at @BCMCancerCenter at @NC…
RT @BCMCancerCenter: Did you know today is World Pancreatic Cancer Day? Learn more about our clinical trials for this disease. https://t.co…
Do economic factors contribute to heart disease death rates? A preliminary study says heart disease deaths increased in counties hit hard by the 2008-09 recession. https://t.co/TkD0lBZn0z via @UPI
MD Anderson Cancer Center@MDAndersonNews
“Don’t delay seeing a doctor if you think something’s wrong. You know your body better than anyone else,” says Herman Connor, a #kidneycancer survivor: https://t.co/O3s3i59PMl #endcancer https://t.co/pmH1LDTmGT
University of Houston@UHouston
We are excited to announce a virtual tour that will allow you to explore campus like never before. Check it out now on our homepage or the UH Go Mobile App. #GoCoogs! https://t.co/MfuoO4vMB8
MD Anderson Cancer Center@MDAndersonNews
@wfpinky @cher @benatargiraldo Safe travels, Marissa.
RT @RiceUNews: We can’t yet build with unlimited piles of diamond, no. But @RiceUniversity researchers have figured out the next best thing…
Harris Health System@harrishealth
More than 34 million Americans smoke, and smoking remains the largest preventable cause of death and illness in the world. Smoking causes an estimated 480,000 deaths every year. Make the decision to quit smoking today! #GreatAmericanSmokeouthttps://t.co/n4c7C3vqTp https://t.co/ebXcuhTouS