People

Essay: Combating Bias and Discrimination in Science and Medicine


Carl E. Josehart is interim COO of Houston's Jewish Family Service and the former CEO and senior vice president of TIRR Memorial Hermann.
By Carl E. Josehart | July 2, 2018

There is much going on in our world that can lead us to doubt whether progress towards equality is possible. We live in a time of rising intolerance, a resurgence in anti-LGBTQ and anti-immigrant sentiments and actions, a renewed attack on women’s reproductive freedoms, and the list goes on. Persistent bias still exists for people of certain religious faiths, people of certain ethnic backgrounds, undocumented immigrants, LGBTQ individuals, the disabled, the poor, the homeless and the mentally ill.

Even if we do not consciously act on them, biases cause harm by impacting who we hire, what we expect and what issues get prioritized for study, research and treatment. Science stands as an important arena to break down barriers and improve acceptance; and yet, as scientists, we are human beings and remain susceptible to society’s biases.

The history of science and medicine is littered with examples of social biases clouding scientific judgment. While it would be easier to believe that these issues are behind us, evidence shows bias and discriminatory beliefs are hardly historical footnotes. A study published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America in 2016 shows that among medical students and residents:

• 25 percent of white respondents believe that blacks have thicker skin than whites

• 30 percent believe that blacks have stronger and denser bones than whites

• 5 to 10 percent believe that nerve endings in blacks are less sensitive than in whites

Overcoming bias takes more than tolerance. It takes more than acceptance. It takes equal representation in all levels of academia, scientific study and clinical practice in order to challenge false beliefs and break the cycle of discriminatory practice.

A range of poor health outcomes has long been associated with communities of color, including depression, cardiovascular disease, infant mortality, preterm labor and low birth-weight. A growing body of evidence shows that negative, harmful physiological changes are caused by the stress of living with discrimination. In other words, discrimination, like smoking, is itself the cause of disease through a process described as “weathering” or allostatic load, according to a study published in the American Journal of Public Health. This evidence challenges us to address discrimination and bias as a public health issue.

In 2016, a woman earned, on average, 79 cents to every dollar paid to a man, with the gap widen-ing to 60 cents for black women and to 55 cents for Hispanic women. Wage disparities contribute to poverty, the single greatest predictor of health outcomes in the United States today. By age 25, Americans with the highest incomes live, on average, more than six years longer than their poor counterparts, and this gap remains throughout life. At age 65, those at the top half of the income distribution live almost five years more than those in the bottom half—a finding that has been consistent since the 1970s, according to data collected by the U.S. Government Accountability Office.

Women have historically been underrepresented in scientific research. Therefore, clinical guidelines in medicine have historically been normed on male subjects, leaving treatment for women sub-optimized or even harmful. A study published in the Journal of Women’s Health in 2011 analyzed whether or not clinical trials funded by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) included women and minorities as participants, as required by the NIH Revitalization Act of 1993. The results were disappointing.

“This research was undertaken to examine studies published in nine high-impact journals in 2009 for compliance with the NIH inclusion and reporting guidelines for sex and race/ethnicity and to compare the results with previous findings from 2004,” the authors wrote. “We found very little improvement over the last 5 years. The median enrollment of women in studies that included both sexes remained low, at 37 percent.”

Representation for people with disabilities is significantly worse. While approximately 20 percent of the U.S. population has a disability, fewer than 1 percent of students with disabilities make up medical school graduating classes. A 2016 U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics report states that a mere 17.9 percent of persons with a disability were employed, compared to 65.3 percent of those without a disability. The medical model of disability that sees disability as a disease, rather than a normal part of life, contributes to bias in employers who routinely report that people with disabilities pose greater risks to their organizations, are less reliable as employees and are less productive. Admitting more students with disabilities to medical school is a critical step in normalizing disability, diminishing the stigma associated with disability and opening up new avenues for research.

With respect to issues of gender identity and sexual orientation, a survey from Stanford’s LGBTQ Medical Education Research Group suggests that medical students do not always feel adequately trained to care for the needs of LGBTQ patients. For example, 74 percent of medical students surveyed felt prepared to care for patients with HIV, while only 25 percent felt prepared for care related to sexual reassignment surgery.

We cannot fight intolerance with ignorance. We need to first start by making sure that all populations are adequately represented as clinicians, scientists, research participants and academics.

Carl E. Josehart is interim COO of Houston’s Jewish Family Service and the former CEO and senior vice president of TIRR Memorial Hermann. This essay was adapted from his 2018 acceptance speech for the Albert Schweitzer Fellowship Humanitarian of the Year Award (asfhg.org), which is bestowed upon individuals who have made great contributions to the community through service.




Social Posts

profile_image

BCMHouston

@bcmhouston

RT @NIH_NIAMS: #NIAMSResearch @BCMHouston: “Rbfox Splicing Factors Maintain Skeletal Muscle Mass by Regulating Calpain3 and Proteostasis.”…

1 min ago
profile_image

CHI St. Luke's Health

@CHI_StLukes

Baylor St. Luke’s Medical Center is the first hospital in the country to take part in Cerus’ RedeS study, a transfusion therapy trial for an innovative technology that can reduce transfusion recipients’ risk of infection from #Zika or #WestNileVirus. https://t.co/BQaCnjizEO https://t.co/s61jNkGMAu

2 mins ago
profile_image

Rice University

@RiceUniversity

RT @fondrenlibrary: In honor of #MandelaDay, here's a link to a @BakerInstitute Report describing Mandela's address @RiceUniversity in Octo…

15 mins ago
profile_image

Rice University

@RiceUniversity

RT @RiceKinderInst: Texas must figure out how to shape future efforts in resilience and disaster preparation for future disasters like #Hur…

25 mins ago
profile_image

BCMHouston

@bcmhouston

RT @BCMHouston_News: Before starting a microbiome-targeting #probiotic regimen, it's important to talk to your doctor, @bcmhouston's Dr. Pr…

31 mins ago
profile_image

Memorial Hermann

@memorialhermann

"One day when Charlie is older, I’ll show him a picture of his smile when he was born—the face I first fell in love with when I met him." Learn more about the pediatric plastic and reconstructive surgical options at Children's Memorial Hermann Hospital: https://t.co/CoOlOts3km https://t.co/cFS4kCr84A

33 mins ago
profile_image

Rice University

@RiceUniversity

It’s all in the details. 🦉#riceuniversity https://t.co/XwGEiL4zjw

45 mins ago
profile_image

BCMHouston

@bcmhouston

The lengths a cancer cell will go to survive might surprise you! https://t.co/GJphyQgP0d @BCMFromtheLabs

1 hour ago
profile_image

Veterans Affairs

@DeptVetAffairs

As a VA doctor, Ken knew VA offered top-quality care so after his injury in Iraq he chose VA for care. Now this Purple Heart recipient continues to serve Veterans every day. Watch his story and #ExploreVA: https://t.co/X47xATHFU6

1 hour ago
profile_image

University of Houston

@UHouston

We've got it covered! With a recent $3 Million gift, the inaugural class of the UH College of Medicine will have their tuition paid in full. Thank you to all of our supporters for helping us address the need for primary care in our community. #UHHereWeGo https://t.co/ywFieVN2H9

1 hour ago
profile_image

TexasHeartInstitute

@Texas_Heart

Chef Amanda DeJesus gave us a meal prep demo for #WellnessWednesday last week. Learned loads and smiled a bunch, too! https://t.co/2x6fEwIwy7

2 hours ago
profile_image

TexasHeartInstitute

@Texas_Heart

RT @ACCmediacenter: Smoking may increase risk of #AFib, research suggests. @HealthDayEditor https://t.co/bsZ4kX8zSG https://t.co/sdSdEiMGVz

2 hours ago
profile_image

MD Anderson Cancer Center

@MDAndersonNews

@lopez_indignado Alberto, we are not the same operation and are not able to address your concerns. We suggest you speak to the El Instituto de Cancerologia about your questions regarding your care. Best wishes to you.

2 hours ago
profile_image

MD Anderson Cancer Center

@MDAndersonNews

.@3Bsgrandma shares how a second opinion revealed a stage IV #breastcancer diagnosis and how a #clinicaltrial offered hope. #bcsm #endcancer https://t.co/utykXMSP2H

2 hours ago
profile_image

MD Anderson Cancer Center

@MDAndersonNews

@lopez_indignado Alberto, unfortunately we can't provide medical advice via Twitter. However, if you'd like to learn about coming to MD Anderson, you can learn about our International Center here: https://t.co/XNiNJ7jqxM. Best wishes to you.

3 hours ago