Health Policy

Health Care Myths and Realities

Some long-held assumptions simply aren’t true


Garson
By Ryan Holeywell | December 5, 2017

Arthur “Tim” Garson Jr., M.D., MPH, who leads the Texas Medical Center Health Policy Institute, is co-author of the book Health Care Half-Truths: Too Many Myths, Not Enough Reality. A physician and former medical school dean, Garson challenges commonly-held notions about the U.S. health care system. He spoke with Pulse about health care “myths.” This interview has been edited for clarity.

PULSE | Does the U.S. really have the best health care in the world?
TG | When you ask people whether the U.S. has the best health care in the world, the vast majority say “yes,” but when you ask how you measure that, you get blank stares. Two major measures are infant mortality and life expectancy. Depending upon the year, the U.S. ranks about 50th in each, which shocks people.

Medical care, on the other hand, is what doctors and nurses and patients do together. How many breast cancer screenings do we perform? What’s the mortality rate for coronary bypass? We are good at a few things—for example the U.S. ranks first in breast cancer mortality. But in the overall index of the rate of preventable deaths, we’re at the bottom of wealthy countries, ranked 18 out of 18.

There’s a frequently cited paper that says 10 percent of life expectancy is due to medical care, and 90 percent is the other things, including 40 percent that is due to people’s own behavior. If we want to improve health care, we can do a lot more by helping people quit smoking, overeating, doing drugs and committing murders.

PULSE | We hear all the time about how preventive care can save money, but you argue that’s not really the case. Could you elaborate?
TG | Let’s be really clear: prevention is important and must be done. But it rarely saves money. There are a lot of things that we do that are good for all kinds of reasons but don’t save money. In the case of prevention, saving money isn’t the point. The point is to keep people healthy.

For example, do immunizations save money? Measles immunizations do, because measles can result in a person becoming brain damaged, living a long time and requiring lots of expensive care. Preventing measles saves money. Some of the other immunizations are important to keeping people healthy, but they just don’t save money.

Here’s a real paradox: In a really well-done study, it was shown that over a very long time frame, smoking actually saves money. Why? If you smoke, you die earlier, and you don’t spend money over the course of a longer life.

 

PULSE | One of the things we’ve heard during the debates about health reform is that people can get insurance if they just go to work. Should we believe that?
TG | No. Uninsured people work. Data show that more than 70 percent of uninsured people come from working families. The real problem is that many of these people work for employers who aren’t offering insurance to their workers. Fewer than half of small businesses offer health insurance to their workers, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.

As we discuss and debate the future of health care in this country, it’s important to understand that today, having a job doesn’t necessarily equate to having insurance.

 

PULSE | You published your book 10 years ago. How have your attitudes about the health care system changed?
TG | I’m more pessimistic now. In 2017, we were just one vote away from taking health insurance away from 20 million people, instead of giving health insurance to more people. I hope that’s a short-term aberration, rather than a view from our leaders who’ve decided the best thing we can do as a country is take health care away from 20 million people.

I was more optimistic in 2007. The last chapter of the book predicted that we would get a better health care system, but it would take a major disaster of some sort. I was wrong. We had the financial collapse in 2008, and despite the Affordable Care Act, there was no fundamental change to health policy. At some point, we’ll have a real safety net system, like just about every other country. We’re the only outlier. What I don’t know is what it will take for us to get there. But we have to keep trying.

……………..

Want to learn about more health care myths? Attend the TMC Health Policy Institute’s event: “True or False? A discussion challenging everything you think you know about health care.” 5:30–7 p.m. on Jan. 9, 2018, at the TMC Health Policy Institute, 6550 Bertner Ave., 6th floor. Free; registration required.




Social Posts

profile_image

Veterans Affairs

@DeptVetAffairs

Veterans town hall provides resources, updates on Eastern Baltimore VA clinic https://t.co/Oq4loKI2h1 via @TheAvenueNews

16 mins ago
profile_image

Veterans Affairs

@DeptVetAffairs

World War II Veteran from East Longmeadow receives medals for service https://t.co/lPInfYWTbt via @WWLP22News

1 hour ago
profile_image

MD Anderson Cancer Center

@MDAndersonNews

@Kevyjoekr @MelDMann Thanks for sharing your experience, Kevin.

2 hours ago
profile_image

BCMHouston

@bcmhouston

One of the worst times to get sick with the Flu? The holidays. Stay safe this holiday season and get your flu shot. Have a question? Our experts have the answers about the flu, and vaccines. https://t.co/5Zi0qvWBgb #flu https://t.co/dHCiJD21Ul

2 hours ago
profile_image

Veterans Affairs

@DeptVetAffairs

Female Veterans honored with day trip to Washington D.C. https://t.co/LmPVjrmGmG via @WESH

2 hours ago

U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs

U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs

Today’s #VeteranOfTheDay is Army Veteran Pat McClurkin.After enlisting in the Army, Pat was commissioned as an officer in the Medical Corps. During her enlistment, Pat served at Walter Reed Medical Center and provided physical therapy for wounded veterans, along with several VIPs. One of her most notable patients was former First Lady Mamie Eisenhower.After serving her four year enlistment, Pat was discharged at the rank of captain and received a commendation from Major General Enrique Mendez, Commander at Walter Reed Army Medical Center, for her dedication to duty, her exceptional performance and her exemplary service.Thank you for your service, Pat!

3 hours ago
profile_image

BCMHouston

@bcmhouston

RT @BCMHouston_News: Family and in-laws can be the source of stress during the #holidays. @bcmhouston's Dr. Asim Shah talks about how to ma…

5 hours ago
profile_image

TAMU Health Sciences

@TAMHSC

RT @healthysouthtx: Managing #diabetes requires so much more than simply taking a pill. For the best results, health pros recommend eating…

5 hours ago
profile_image

Houston Methodist

@MethodistHosp

#HoustonMethodist’s Center for Performing Arts Medicine worked with our emergency department to bring a new sense of calm to what is usually a stressful environment. Our employee art now offers warmth and serenity to those waiting in the #ER. https://t.co/Pz5i5uIKSC

5 hours ago
profile_image

MD Anderson Cancer Center

@MDAndersonNews

Thanks to a $1 million gift from @SU2C, there's revitalized hope in expanding #immunotherapy to #pancreaticcancer: https://t.co/QzfMrVXoEf #pancsm #endcancer

5 hours ago
profile_image

MD Anderson Cancer Center

@MDAndersonNews

A clinical trial studying a combination of #immunotherapy and #chemo offers Barbara Lewis hope when faced with triple-negative breast cancer: https://t.co/EJdCT5EGIO #BCSM #CancerMoonshot #endcancer

5 hours ago
profile_image

Rice University

@RiceUniversity

RT @RiceEngineering: ICYMI | ‘Smart skin’ warns of strain in bridges and airplanes. Read at @FuturityNews: https://t.co/qU6IsaeUv3 https://…

5 hours ago
profile_image

UTMB Health

@utmbhealth

RT @jbmilliken: Ran across Ashbel Smith, first chairman of the UT Board of Regents, while touring ⁦@utmbhealth⁩ https://t.co/R3hvSmVAWk

6 hours ago
profile_image

UTMB Health

@utmbhealth

RT @utsystem: Chancellor @jbmilliken continues his visits to #utsystem institutions, this time to @utmbhealth, which has been #InServiceToT…

6 hours ago
profile_image

Harris Health System

HarrisHealthSystem

On Thursday, Nov. 15, Lyndon B. Johnson Hospital hosted its sixth annual Shine a Light on Lung Cancer event to raise awareness and educate to patients and staff about the deadly disease that kills more people—in both men and women—than any other cancer.Dr. Tina Cascone, assistant professor, Medical Oncology, LBJ, MD Anderson, opened the ceremony with an informative presentation discussing various forms of cancer treatment and the rates of success associated with each. Moments later, Chris Benefiel gave an endearing testimony of his care as a Harris Health patient.In August of last year, Chris was diagnosed with stage 3B lung cancer at another Houston Hospital, but without medical insurance, he could not receive treatment. He then applied for Harris Health's financial assistance program and received treatment at Smith Clinic.He spent the next few months depressed as he battled the disease. One day, with Harris Health's help, he decided to take control of his cancer and began looking at the positive aspects of his life.Dr. Hilary Ma, chief, Medical Oncology, LBJ, MD Anderson, delivered an update on LBJ's Oncology Program. He was excited the hospital received its recertification with the Commission on Cancer, which ensures the hospital delivers the highest caliber of cancer care.He announced that talks have begun to open a new comprehensive cancer center at LBJ, uniting the radiation department, the infusion center, patient educators and case management in one area.Cletus Udoh, supervisor, Chaplain Services, LBJ, has experienced the devastation of cancer. After visiting some sad, discouraged cancer patients, Cletus recognized their hopelessness and wanted to do something to empower them.He began searching for an idea to raise awareness about cancer six years ago, which he would later find online through the Lung Cancer Alliance. He considers this event as an opportunity to let patients know the organization is here for them and that they are not alone in their journey."We provide basic educational information and guidance to our community so we can proactively reduce the number of people who face lung cancer in the future," Cletus says. "Healthcare in 2018 is heading toward a new model. We don't want to cure this disease—we want to prevent it."For patients like Chris, treatment at Harris Health, in conjunction with educational programs like Shine a Light, has proved life changing."Without Harris Health, I had no hope for treatment or a future," Chris says. "The care here has been exceptional and I'm so thankful to Harris Health and its staff—they have given me the last 12 months of my life."

6 hours ago