Poll Shows Widespread Support For Increasing Smoking Age To 21


cigarette
By Ryan Holeywell, Texas Medical Center Health Policy Institute | October 19, 2017

New research shows that Americans of overwhelming support increasing from 18 to 21 the age at which people can legally purchase tobacco products.

A poll of more than 5,000 adults across five states shows that 80 percent of respondents support the policy, known as Tobacco 21.

But perhaps even more importantly, a deep dive of the polling data reveals strong support for Tobacco 21 not only across political parties but across racial, educational and income groups. The new analysis is based on data from a 2016 survey by the Texas Medical Center Health Policy Institute that was published last month in the journal Nicotine & Tobacco Research.

This year, Maine, New Jersey and Oregon each raised their legal age for purchasing tobacco from 18 to 21, joining California and Hawaii, which enacted the change in previous years. Dozens of cities also have Tobacco 21 laws on the books, including Boston, Chicago, Columbus, Kansas City, New York and San Francisco. Federal regulations set the national minimum age for tobacco at 18, but states and most localities are allowed to restrict sales to those older than 18 if they choose to.

The study’s authors say lawmakers should view the survey results as a sign that voters of many types largely support the idea of raising the legal age for purchasing tobacco.

“Policymakers interested in enacting Tobacco 21 laws should be heartened by strong public support at the state level, regardless of demographic, health status or political characteristics,” the authors write.

The paper was written by Stephanie Morain, assistant professor at Baylor College of Medicine’s Center for Medical Ethics & Health Policy; Jean Raphael, associate professor of pediatrics at Baylor College of Medicine and director of the Texas Children’s Hospital Center for Child Health Policy and Advocacy and Arthur Garson, director of the Texas Medical Center Health Policy Institute;

The TMC survey was conducted last year and questioned more than 5,000 adults across five states: California, Florida, New York, Ohio and Texas. Despite widespread support for Tobacco 21, some differences emerge. By and large, older people are more likely to support it than younger people. In Florida and Ohio, support from black respondents was 25 percent and 15 percent lower than support from white respondents. Across all five states, support for Tobacco 21 was strongest among those with the most education.

Interestingly, Republicans – often associated with small government and an aversion towards regulation – were more supportive of the proposal than Democrats in four of the five states.

More than 16 million Americans live with at least one disease caused by smoking, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Tobacco 21 advocates aim to put a dent in that number.

In most places in the U.S., consumers have to be at least 18-years-old to purchase tobacco products. Raise that age to 21, advocates say, and something interesting happens: suddenly, younger high school students would be unable to get cigarettes from older high school students, their primary source of smokes.

Advocates for Tobacco 21 say young people are particularly susceptible to marketing and especially vulnerable to nicotine’s addictive effects. They need less nicotine than adults to become fully addicted, and yet, their heightened impulsivity prevents them from taking heed of that heightened risk. They reason that if you can prevent young people from taking up smoking as teens, you can prevent many of them from becoming lifelong smokers as adults.

The concept has won the endorsement from dozens of entities, from the American Heart Association to the National Academy of Medicine. In 2016, a New England Journal of Medicine op-ed called the concept “an idea whose time has come.”

“Policymakers from both side of the political aisle can support these laws, without fear of voter backlash,” the authors write.

Still, not everyone supports the concept. In Texas, several Tobacco 21 bills were introduced during the most recent legislative session, but neither were put to a vote in the full state House or Senate. Critics say the laws violate principles of the “free market” and “individual liberty,” and retailers point to the financial impact of reduced sales.

“Tobacco is not quite as evil as maybe we think,” said Phil Metzinger, an executive with Brookshire Brothers, a Texas grocery chain, in testimony before a Texas committee considering a Tobacco 21 bill earlier this year. He warned of the consequences of depriving Texans of “basic human rights.” (Morain, one of the authors of the survey study, wrote a separate article rebutting those arguments.)

Others point to the lost state revenue that would come from reduced tobacco revenue. Texas’ legislative budget office estimates a Tobacco 21 bill would cost the state more than $5 million annually in lost revenue, starting in 2021.

Interestingly, even those most directly affected by Tobacco laws – 18-to 21-year-olds – overwhelming support them, with 69 percent in that age range favoring increasing the age at which tobacco can be purchased.

The researchers write that the results might have particular significance for lawmakers in conservative areas, which historically haven’t been as quick to take up Tobacco 21 laws. That may be because of a phenomenon identified in other studies: legislators tend to overestimate just how conservative their constituents really are.

The researchers found another interesting trend that should be welcome news to Tobacco 21 advocates. Support for the legislation is strongest among categories of people who are most likely to vote: older, white people with high levels of education.

Social Posts

profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

We're giving away nearly $1 million in grants to @TXMedCenter members to support programs that reduce health disparities. More information at https://t.co/4PvDw4YNib https://t.co/E6gz5tVGc2

4 days ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

RT @RyanHoleywell: @jenny_deam of the @HoustonChron writes eloquently about how the administration's shift on pre-existing conditions could…

4 days ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Houston healthcare providers are making great strides in developing shareable electronic health records. But work remains. “It’s getting better," one doctor said, "but I think it’s going to take longer than we thought." https://t.co/ENFW0tGqfZ @TXMedCenter https://t.co/vWLAMMFvlk

5 days ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

“It seems that the public in Texas wants the legislature to do something,” said Dr. Tim Garson, who heads the @TXMedCenter Health Policy Institute. Read our take on the new @Health4Texas / @KaiserFamFound survey, via @HoustonPubMedia https://t.co/YhWGgQGoUm https://t.co/ZEJaRQdJdq

7 days ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

"Justice Dept. Says Crucial Provisions of Obamacare Are Unconstitutional." Read the latest from @NYTHealth https://t.co/1i6IQyYuPp

2 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

.@utmbhealth's Tom Geisbert helped create the #Ebola vaccine that, for the first time, is being used to help stop a new outbreak. Read more about his career trying to protect the world from one of its most deadly diseases https://t.co/BpaIY5xKi2 https://t.co/Q1oOhOCwRr

4 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

If school's out, but you're still eager to learn, check out the free @TXMedCenter Health Policy Course. Watch our lectures online and learn how health policy in the U.S. REALLY works. Best of all: it's free. More info at https://t.co/Hg24jPlIai #healthpolicy https://t.co/XnqKoyObho

4 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Those home ancestry kits might be fun. But you may want to think twice about taking one, now that police are using them in their investigations. Read more from Jessica Roberts of @TXMedCenter and @UHLAW in @ChronOpinion https://t.co/6anxc653Rh https://t.co/3cjwt6o7l1

1 month ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Put that in the context of health care: the average deductible for employer-provided insurance is $1,500. The average deductible for many ACA plans exceeds $4,000. Many Americans can't come anywhere close to paying that amount. https://t.co/VtD0VNN9nI

1 month ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

40% of Americans can't cover a $400 emergency expense https://t.co/YtIea6NHSa via @CNNMoney

1 month ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Hear how the @TXMedCenter is working to support @UHouston researchers in their fight against drug resistant fungus. https://t.co/XPij5kmi9M https://t.co/lxUx0ezm3G

1 month ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Insurers are trying a new approach to dealing with high ER costs. But patients say they're getting caught in the crosshairs. What do you think of this strategy? https://t.co/DsYaSYdaQh https://t.co/GHqxSsughx

1 month ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

RT @TXMedCenter: Our hearts go out to the students and faculty impacted by the shooting at #SantaFe High School. TMC hospitals are treating…

1 month ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

New research from @bcmhouston and @TexasChildrens explores the best ways to implement screening for social determinants of health #sdoh https://t.co/8bLm0TjXCL https://t.co/dKVe5JHlAh

1 month ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Latest from @jenny_deam via @HoustonChron. Scary trend in TX: uninsured rate climbing up again. "The rate of working age adults without health coverage has ticked up to about 15.5 percent so far in 2018, up from 12.7 percent in 2016." https://t.co/KGwIEZbaTT healthpolicy https://t.co/7C6BRieUnO

1 month ago