Both Parties Can Win if We Cut Health Care Costs: Column


radiology11 Flickr/NIHClinicalCenter
By Arthur Garson, Jr., MD, MPH, MACC, Director, TMC Health Policy Institute | May 04, 2017

There’s a trillion dollars of waste in our health care system.

 Largely absent from the current health-care debate in Washington is one astonishing number: We waste fully one-third of our medical care dollars, about $1 trillion out of $3 trillion annually, according to a paper by Donald Berwick and Andrew Hackbarth that was published in The Journal of the American Medical Association.

After practicing medicine for almost 40 years, including 20 in health policy, I’ve become convinced that to achieve adequate, affordable health care for all Americans, the cost of care must be reduced.

Attacking cost, of course, is politically unpopular. The savings might make providers and companies less profitable, and businesses lobby heavily. So how do we go after that $1 trillion in waste? Here are four suggestions:

1. Take a big chunk out of the $192 billion spent on overtreatment. One reason for overtreatment — doing things that should not be done or don’t need to be done — is that doctors are paid for each procedure they do, so-called fee-for-service. I have watched salespeople for medical equipment tell a physician how many tests they have to do to pay for the machine. Don’t tell me that there isn’t a little bit of that conversation (perhaps unconsciously) going into that physician’s decision on who needs that test.

We can fix this by taking away the stimulus away to do more and more. All physicians should receive a salary (at their current compensation, not lower) plus a bonus based on quality. In some of the best health care systems in the United States — such as the Mayo Clinic, Cleveland Clinic and Kaiser Permanente — physicians are paid a salary. Payers such as Medicare or Blue Cross could give a bonus to health systems that give physicians a salary.

2. Permit Medicare to consider cost in evaluating what to pay for, which is currently illegal. The federal government and states should then evaluate the cost and effectiveness of mandates for what must be covered by insurance. Having these data would make it a lot easier to create a low-deductible catastrophic plan that is affordable and would attract healthy people.

Another ripe target is the cost of prescription drugs. Depending on the assumptions, permitting Medicare to negotiate drug prices would produce savings of anywhere from a small amount to more than $100 billion over 10 years. Everyone from President Trump to liberal Democrats has good ideas about drug prices, resoundingly supported by the public and opposed by the pharmaceutical manufacturers. Here’s an idea: Ask the drugmakers to propose ways to cut costs over time that they could live with.

3. Reform Medicaid with similar efficiencies. Medicaid mandates should be examined for cost effectiveness. The Republican plan to repeal and replace Obamacare would allow states to receive a set amount of money (a “block grant” or “per capita cap”) in return for more flexibility. States should look carefully at possible outcomes under these new payment models. Perhaps a new single program with more state control should be created for low-income people (currently covered by Medicaid and exchanges) with modern rules for who should be covered. Medicaid dates to 1965, when health insurance was a lot less expensive and provided by almost all employers.

4. Give patients more incentives to do their share. We need to improve mechanisms to get people to maintain normal body weight and take their medications, and to discourage behaviors such as smoking, overeating and using emergency department for non-emergencies. If smoking and obesity were eliminated, life expectancy would increase by four years.

Changing behavior is tough. It does seem that “people need people,” and the American Diabetes Association has recommended paraprofessionals such as coaches and navigators to help establish good habits in management of diabetes.

Finally, patients should become prudent buyers, which requires greater price transparency. Is there any other product you consume without having any idea up front how much it will cost? Insurance information and pricing must be available to individuals and families, at a person’s educational level. The University of Virginia has developed the “TEACH” questionnaire that asks individuals how they want their health information and then gives the information in that format.

The Affordable Care Act extended insurance coverage to tens of millions of people but did little to make health care, well, more affordable. The Republicans’ latest repeal-and-replace plan, which might or might not come to a House vote this week or next, would curb government spending on health care but toss tens of millions of people off the insurance rolls.

By reducing the cost of health care, Republicans and Democrats can both have what they want: fewer entitlements, and more people covered with insurance.

Without bipartisan support, something as important and complicated as overhauling our nation’s health care system will never happen.  But each attempt will continue ultimately to be doomed to failure without recognition of one fact: It’s the cost, stupid.

Originally published on USATODAY.com

Social Posts

profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

RT @TXMedCenter: The #TMC3 campus will be a monumental project in the @TXMedCenter establishing #Houston as the “Third Coast” for life #sciences competing with Boston & San Francisco in the critical mission of advancing medical #research. https://t.co/q2V7vgf0YV #innovation

3 hours ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

TX @GovAbbott announcing @TXMedCenter's newest project: the groundbreaking #TMC3 project. More info at https://t.co/iLi4vnheks. https://t.co/201Fwl1r6L

3 hours ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Americans overwhelmingly say that when it’s time to die, they’d prefer to go at home. But the reality is that 1 in 4 elderly people die in the ICU. Why the discrepancy? Learn in @TXMedCenter Pulse magazine. #healthpolicy https://t.co/Ah0IT3lM5D https://t.co/doWVMROITi

1 day ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy Institute

HealthPolicyTMC

Texas is suing the feds in hopes of eliminating the ACA. Instead, it should "redirect its energy toward building on existing efforts to improve access to cost-effective health care for all Texans," our colleague Vivian Ho of James A. Baker III Institute for Public Policy writes in Texas Tribune's TribTalk.

6 days ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Texas is suing the feds in hopes of eliminating the ACA. Instead, it should "redirect its energy toward building on existing efforts to improve access to cost-effective health care for all," our colleague @HealthEconTX writes in @TexasTribune https://t.co/YWRXIsK8iv #healthpolicy https://t.co/joCQ301waN

6 days ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Advancements in medicine have increased life expectancy in the U.S., but not without repercussions, including a steady rise in the cost of care. Read more insights from our latest event at the @TXMedCenter #HealthPolicy #HealthCareFuture https://t.co/X7hA7RXJId https://t.co/qWNvdi59un

1 week ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy Institute

HealthPolicyTMC

Advancements in medicine have increased life expectancy in the U.S., but not without repercussions, including a steady rise in the cost of care. Read more insights from our latest event at the Texas Medical Center.

1 week ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

RT @ryanhuey: e.g. One of my patients today couldn’t get chemotherapy for the last 2 months because he lost his phone and doesn’t have a ca…

2 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

One big, simple reason for the growing cost of health care that nobody wants to mention: GREED, says Michael Ewer, drawing applause from room full of health care professionals #HealthCareFuture

2 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Thank you for coming every week! RT @ericbakota: Great turnout at the final #TMCPolicyCourse to discuss #HealthCareFuture . Thanks @HealthPolicyTMC for putting this on! https://t.co/V4heixuLUn

2 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

"If we take the time to listen to the patient, we don't have to order as many tests." Science will never totally replace the "art of medicine," says @UHouston's Dr. Steve Spann #HealthCareFuture

2 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Thanks for joining us! RT @ryanhuey: Perks of working in the world’s largest medical center: great panel by @HealthPolicyTMC about US health care and its future. #HealthCareFuture https://t.co/zywIaAJOy0

2 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

RT @ToriV_24: We need to change sick care to preventative care! We end up saving more money in the long run. #tmcpolicycourse #healthcarefu…

2 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy Institute

HealthPolicyTMC

What does the future hold for health care reform in the U.S.? Join our conversation happening NOW at the Texas Medical Center and watch live at the link below. #HealthCareFuture

2 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

What's right about the U.S. health care? We innovate for the rest of the world. What's wrong? Just about everything else, says our director Dr. Tim Garson #HealthCareFuture https://t.co/LYYD8C9wX2

2 weeks ago