Throughout the third and final presidential debate, Secretary Clinton and Mr. Trump disagreed on nearly every issue, but they did agree on one thing: the Affordable Care Act (ACA) is not affordable. And that is a huge problem.
In the recent Texas Medical Center Nielsen survey, 96 percent of Texans said having health insurance was important, but still about 17 percent remain uninsured, which puts Texas’ number of uninsured as highest in the nation. We found that respondents said cost was the major barrier to having health insurance, and 87 percent of uninsured who visited the health marketplace exchange could not afford insurance. For example, an individual making $22,000 per year (200 percent of the Federal Poverty Level) could not afford to purchase a plan in the marketplace that required him or her to pay a $6,400 premium before insurance kicks in. That equals about 28 percent of that individual’s income. Estimates of what is considered “affordable health care” vary from two to eight percent of an individual’s income, but surely not 28 percent!
So how do we attack the problem that individuals just don’t have the money to pay for health insurance, i.e. without the help of a large employer footing most of the bill? There really is only one way to solve it: decrease the cost of health care.
Step one should be dramatically decreasing the waste in health care. In the U.S.,one third of our health care dollars are wasted. Shocking, isn’t it? When I first heard this number, I was skeptical that it’s accurate, until I read how Dr. Donald Berwick, a highly respected health economics expert, analyzed the numbers. Of $3 trillion a year in health care expenditures in the U.S., about $910 billion, or 30 percent, is wasted. Of this, we waste $192 billion on overtreatment, i.e. doing procedures and tests that are unnecessary. In West Virginia, for example, a patient is seven times more likely to have a heart procedure than in San Francisco, but the patients in West Virginia are no sicker and do not have better results, implying that many in West Virginia did not need the procedure in the first place and were “overtreated.” There are a number of possible reasons for this overtreatment, but a prominent one is that the doctors doing these procedures are paid per procedure—the so called “fee-for-service” model of health care.
The largest payer in the U.S., the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), recognizes this fact and has committed to paying physicians at least 50 percent using a value-based payment. This “value-based health care” model—by very definition not fee-for-service—will reimburse for quality of health care instead of quantity of procedures by the end of 2018. The most sensible way to deliver value-based care is to pay physicians a salary. In some of the best health care systems in the U.S.—Mayo Clinic, Cleveland Clinic and Kaiser Permanente—physicians are paid a salary, in most cases with an additional bonus based on quality metrics like patient satisfaction or positive outcomes like reducing readmissions to the hospital.
The future of health care depends on getting all interested parties on board with a transition to value-based care. Some payers worry that when physicians are paid a salary, they will see fewer patients. The solution here is to pay a quality bonus based on standards set by physicians. The other side of the coin is that physicians worry their incomes will fall. On the contrary, salary can be quite high, even the same as what a physician earns now, in the value-based model. To ensure adequate and fair pay for physicians who are just ramping up their practice, we could develop a compensation system for those in their first years of practice to incrementally increase over five years until it reaches the current salary for that type of physician in the region. The savings reaped to the system from a reduction in unnecessary tests, procedures and hospitalizations (overtreatment) far exceeds what it will take to pay physicians higher salaries and quality bonuses.
What needs to happen to make affordable health care a reality?
1. The savings must be monitored and captured, which is no small feat. Paying physicians a salary could cut 10 – 15 percent of the nation’s cost of health care, and that savings of $300 million a year could be passed on to individuals in the form of reduced premiums, making the ACA more affordable.
2. The commercial payers such as Blue Cross Blue Shield, as well as Medicare and Medicaid, over the next five years should require that health plans salary their physicians with added quality bonus. This would cover the vast majority of physicians who practice medicine in the U.S. For independent physicians and small group practices, this method may be more difficult to implement and fee-for-service may continue long into the future, though.
Why does this matter to patients? The number of unnecessary tests, procedures and hospitalizations—each carrying some risk—will markedly decrease. And by focusing on delivering high quality care instead of high volume of care, physicians will have more time to see patients, and the in-and-out, eight-minute visit with your doctor will be a thing of the past.
Originally published on Huffington Post
"There is no question that health care spending in this country has spiraled out of control, and it is affecting the day-to-day lives of the people that work hard to earn a living in this country," said Dr. Arthur "Tim" Garson, director of Texas Medical Center Health Policy Institute.
We're bringing together some of the greatest minds in the Texas Medical Center to answer one critical question: What's the future of U.S. Health Care? Register to join us April 10 for this important, interactive discussion.
Join us for our next big panel discussion, "U.S. Health Care: Where Do We Go Next?" 4/10 at @TXMedCenter. Featuring leaders from @harrishealth @UHouston @UHLAW @UTHealth @UTexasSPH @txwomans. Best of all: it's free. Register https://t.co/NYzvQGJbPQ https://t.co/WPPlmuJB1C
In the U.S., we spend $3.4 trillion on health care every year -- $10,000 for every man, woman and child. Fierce Healthcare covers our brand new white paper that offers 8 ways to reduce that sum.
Join us for our next big panel discussion, "U.S. Health Care: Where Do We Go Next?" 4/10 at @TXMedCenter. Featuring leaders from @harrishealth @UHouston @UHLAW @UTHealth @UTexasSPH @txwomans. Best of all: it's free. Register https://t.co/NYzvQGrAYi https://t.co/aFyfM6UvNp
Tomorrow night, we're hosting another session of our #TMCPolicyCourse with experts from @UHLAW @CHCTexas @Health4Texas & @CGAGroup. Attend in-person or online. Details, registration, and livestream link at https://t.co/Hg24jPlIai https://t.co/OOfS9h6MPZ
Join us for our next big panel discussion, "U.S. Health Care: Where Do We Go Next?" 4/10 at @TXMedCenter. Featuring leaders from @harrishealth @UHouston @UHLAW @UTHealth @UTexasSPH @txwomans. Best of all: it's free. Register https://t.co/NYzvQGJbPQ https://t.co/9yoLn9qato
RT @HealthyTexans: ICYMI: important news and insights from @HealthPolicyTMC https://t.co/fAwWq6dqsz
Join us for our next big panel discussion, "U.S. Health Care: Where Do We Go Next?" 4/10 at @TXMedCenter. Featuring leaders from @harrishealth @UHouston @UHLAW @UTHealth @UTexasSPH @txwomans. Best of all: it's free. Register https://t.co/NYzvQGrAYi https://t.co/t94bORaXQz
We're speaking tonight with leaders from @hcphtx @bcmhouston @Immunize_USA and @Rice_Biz about the public health system. Want to join the conversation? 1) Live stream here https://t.co/Hg24jPlIai 2) Tweet using hashtag #TMCPolicyCourse https://t.co/z6IkTGGesc
RT @statnews: Opinion from @HealthPolicyTMC: Many consumers are unlikely to understand that the insurer is really saying, “Be careful: this…
@MHHmeyer thanks for the kind words. It's a huge problem.
RT @SMorain: Important policy read from @HealthPolicyTMC Tim Garson on (lack of) transparency & info provided to consumers of short-term in…
Tonight we're hosting an important talk on the public health system, led by experts from @hcphtx @bcmhouston @Rice_Biz & @Immunize_USA. Join us at the @TXMedCenter at 5:30 pm, or click to stream live https://t.co/Hg24jPlIai #TMCPolicyCourse https://t.co/E0UjdRFB49
Insurers need to do a better job ensuring patients understand exactly what they're buying, we argue in a new @statnews op-ed. https://t.co/ecLCjqBbqm @TXMedCenter https://t.co/6G8MUpa7pT