An Economist’s Perspective on the Health Risks of Watching the Super Bowl: Do Houstonians Have Anything to Fear in 2017?


stethoscope Flickr/allenandallen.com
By Vivian Ho, Ph.D., Director of the Center for Health and Biosciences at Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy | September 20, 2016

I’m a health economist. Some people know me for my commentary on the strengths and weaknesses of the Affordable Care Act, AKA Obamacare. Some physicians at the Texas Medical Center think that we health economists spend our days estimating the cost-per-life-year saved of various drugs and medical treatments. We actually venture more broadly than that. In the past year, I’ve studied the clinically popular notion that cancer patients treated at hospitals that perform more operations are less likely to die in-hospital. I’ve been writing about Texans’ lack of understanding of basic health insurance terminology too.

Sometimes, economists look through a more general lens.  I found a recent article in the American Journal of Health Economics particularly applicable to the upcoming Super Bowl in Houston: Success is Something to Sneeze at: Influenza Mortality in Cities that Participate in the Super Bowl. The CDC and others want to know how changes in where, when, and how large numbers of individuals socialize can influence influenza pandemics. The Super Bowl represents an ideal opportunity to study the effects of changes in “mixing patterns,” because fans of the teams playing in the Super Bowl are more likely to gather to view the game together, and the hosting city experiences a substantial influx of people coming to watch the game.

In this study, a Tulane economist named Charles Stoecker and his coauthors combined data on death records, population, and weather with dates and locations of Super Bowls between 1974 and 2009. They applied statistical analyses to measure whether the annual influenza mortality rate rises in counties that have a team in that year’s Super Bowl or the county where the game is played (e.g. Houston). Examining multiple years of data is particularly helpful, because mortality rates in a championship team’s county can be compared to years when the team didn’t make it to the Super Bowl, and to concurrent influenza mortality in counties with an NFL team that were not in the Super Bowl that year.

The authors find that sending a team to the Super Bowl leads to an additional seven influenza deaths per million for those aged 65 and over in the team’s home county. This increase is 18 percent over the entire sample’s average of 40.7 reported influenza deaths per million elderly. When all ages were considered, there was no increase in the influenza mortality rate in a team’s home county – i.e. the effect on those 65 and over was diluted when the entire population was considered. This led to the conclusion that the spread of the influenza virus that occurs when people socialize during the Super Bowl and this spread is particularly dangerous to people over 65.

Surprisingly, the researchers find no increase in mortality around the Super Bowl for the hosting city. The author hypothesizes this is because the game has traditionally been held in warmer locales where the environment is less favorable for transmission. So what does this mean for Houston come February 2017? Can we forget the hand sanitizer and throw caution to the wind when going to a Super Bowl party? It’s probably better to play it safe than sorry. It’s the cities sending teams that need to be on the alert for a spike in need for influenza care. Perhaps we could get the NFL to pay for commercials encouraging people to get flu vaccinations and be very careful to wash their hands during Super Bowl parties in the conference championship cities. I’ve even got a commercial jingle: “Don’t get sacked at the Super Bowl. A flu shot is your best defense.”

Social Posts

profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Three states yesterday voted to expand Medicaid coverage. Not a surprise: our survey results show that nationwide, there's widespread support for opening up Medicaid to more people. https://t.co/PQDBoayCAQ https://t.co/OtMXLgZ6bM

1 week ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Health policy and medicine meet space at this free event at @UHLAW tomorrow featuring Astronaut Lee M. Morin https://t.co/XDLKDjNnUZ https://t.co/P0hSULV4tu

2 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

"Short-term health insurance should worry you even if you don’t need it." Our colleague Vivian Ho writes for @statnews about the new health insurance plans that threaten to cause big problems https://t.co/3vr9VVGnB7 @HealthEconTX @BakerInstitute @TXMedCenter https://t.co/174pMwPje5

3 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

We've got a wonderful crowd tonight at our Great Health Care Debate here at the @TXMedCenter. We're discussing, debating, and arguing about some of the most important issues facing voters, two weeks before Election Day. Follow along at #TMCdebate. https://t.co/2KivWtdFo2

3 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

We're making last minute preparations for our Great Health Care Debate! Join us at 5:30 pm TONIGHT at @ThirdCoastHou and follow the conversation using #TMCDebate. Free registration https://t.co/z4Zu8ZhaFb @TXMedCenter https://t.co/sLtYo9fUcB

3 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

@ENDHIVHou Unfortunately this one isn't being livestreamed or recorded.

3 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

How drunk is too drunk to drive? Utah will soon lower its blood alcohol threshold while driving from .08 to .05. We think other states should do the same — and more. Our #TMCsurvey shows most Americans agree. Read our latest in @GOVERNING @gov_institute https://t.co/2UsZpfpy66 https://t.co/xjsNHdrt0V

3 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

We spoke with @KPRC2 @KPRC2Haley about why we believe the cost of health care is poised to be a pivotal issue in the 2018 mid-term elections: https://t.co/s4ReUttbby @TXMedCenter https://t.co/yGlQ2GrGau

4 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Our new op-ed in @USATODAY @usatodayopinion makes the case for a "single-safety net" health care system. "If we want all Americans to have insurance coverage, everyone will need a safety net. But we don’t need to destroy the private insurance system." https://t.co/HV63kjgvtt

4 weeks ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Join us next week as we debate some of the pivotal issues at the core of the 2018 campaign. https://t.co/EoejRWthy6 https://t.co/KQqnxLlxhJ

1 month ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Excited to be at the @BakerInstitute this morning learning about how universal health care works in UK, Canada, Germany and Taiwan. Important topic to discuss with health care on the minds of so many US voters. #healthpolicy https://t.co/jVAHk5aiNT

1 month ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

Join us at our @TXMedCenter healthcare debate, where we'll discuss hot-button issues like "Medicare for all" with experts from @txwomans @CHCTexas @UTHealth @bcmhouston @McGovernMed @harrishealth @LegacyCommunity Oct. 25 in Houston. Free registration at https://t.co/EoejRWthy6 https://t.co/TvDokfzDIY

1 month ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

"Do we want our friends to take on second jobs if they get sick? Do we want family members to lose their retirement savings if they suffer an accident?" Citizens of other countries have answered 'no.' When will the U.S. make that choice?" via @TXMedCenter https://t.co/4SfYcqTfQG https://t.co/x471TEnGOo

1 month ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

New @POLITICO story includes coverage of our @TXMedCenter consumer survey: "Will Beto’s bet on Medicaid expansion pay off? Democrats’ past attempts to campaign on that issue fell flat, but there are signs this year might be different." #TMCsurvey https://t.co/REm5Yr3FpL https://t.co/YhE4xcq1iU

2 months ago
profile_image

TMC Health Policy

@HealthPolicyTMC

RT @TXMedCenter: Congratulations to @MDAndersonNews James Allison, Ph.D., who has jointly won the 2018 #NobelPrize in Physiology or Medicin…

2 months ago